they counted

Amazon Renewed · would buy again

The Witch audiobook by Freida McFadden

8 said yes, 0 said no.

Yes. A safe pick for thriller fans, especially around Halloween, with listeners unanimously saying they'd buy it again.

See it on AmazonPrice unavailable at Amazon

Reviews last counted October 29, 2026

In short

The Witch is a 9.5-hour McFadden thriller audiobook, and listeners describe it as twisty, gripping, and easy to get into.

Good for

Anyone who likes fast psychological thrillers with dual timelines, or wants a spooky-season listen, whether new to McFadden or a longtime fan.

The counts

Each row is a yes-or-no question. Not every review answered every question.

  • Does the job8 yes0 no
  • Failed0 yes8 no
  • Would buy again8 yes0 no
  • Worth the price8 yes0 no
  • Matches the description8 yes0 no
  • Broke or stopped working0 yes8 no
  • Better than expected3 yes1 no
  • About the seller or shipping, not the product0 yes0 no

We counted 8 reviews. We left out 0 reviews that were only about delivery.

What they said

Would buy againYes

“Perfect read for Halloween time! Loved it and would highly recommend it..whether it’s your first or 12th Freida Mc Fadden book, you will be intrigued!”

Would buy againYes

“Great book! Keeps you guessing the whole time. So many twists and turns. Easy to get into and keeps you interested the whole book. Really good read.”

Would buy againYes

“This was a great read. Perfect to read during Halloween season. McFadden always surprises me. Great author. Must read. Couldn’t put it down.”

Would buy againYes

“Highly recommend this book by Freida McFadden! I loved the dual POV/timeline thought the entirety of the book. Fantastic character development!”

Would buy againYes

“Loved this book! Great story, great characters in a a before and after. As always Freida has a huge twist in the end”

Would buy againYes

“As always, Freida does not disappoint! Twists and turns and I loved reading about characters from different centuries. Her fans will enjoy it.”

Would buy againYes

“Excellent story. Freida does not disappoint. I love how easily she moves the story from the present to the past. Ready for her next book!”

Would buy againYes

“What a fun read this book was it had me questioning everything and everyone! Pemberton is truly a house of secrets that many will stay hidden!”